Even professional investment analysts struggle to put an exact valuation on Macquarie Group Ltd (ASX:MQG) shares. Despite the challenge, in this short article we’ll take a look at the company through the lens of a good analyst.
Macquarie Group is Australia’s largest investment bank with operations spread throughout North America, Europe, Middle East, Asia and Australia. Unlike a traditional ‘retail’ bank, like most investment banks Macquarie makes a large chunk of its profit by operating in the investment markets and managing ‘assets’ for individuals and organisations. As of 2019, Macquarie had reported a profit for 50 years in a row.
The different ways you can size up a share like MQG
1. Culture is king
Culture and workplace satisfaction are more than just a ‘fluffy’ modern corporate gimmicks. Good workplace culture leads to improved retention of high-quality staff and that ultimately determines the long-term success of a company.
One way Australian investors can take a ‘look inside’ a company like Macquarie Group Ltd is to use Seek company reviews data. According to the most recent data we pulled on MQG the company’s overall workplace culture rating of 3.2/5 was below the sector average of 3.23.
2. Margins are being squeezed
Banks like MQG need debt and good margins to make their model profitable. In basic terms, a bank will take money from term deposit holders and ‘wholesale debt investors’ to lend that money out to homeowners, businesses and investors. The difference between what a bank pays to savers and what it makes from mortgage holders (for example) is the net interest margin or NIM. When it comes to NIMs, the wider the margin, the better.
When you’re forecasting the profits of a bank like MQG or Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Ltd (ASX:BEN), knowing how much the bank lends and what it makes per dollar lent is essential. That’s why the NIM is arguably the most important measure of a bank’s profitability. Across all of the ASX’s major banks, we calculated the average NIM was 2.01% whereas the bank’s lending margin was 2.24%, which means the bank was able to produce a better-than-average return from lending money to customers versus its peers.
The reason for studying the NIM so closely is because Macquarie Group Ltd earned 14.% of its total income from lending last year.
[ls_content_block id=”3409″ para=”paragraphs”]
3. ROE: the measure of quality
Return on equity or ‘ROE’ for short compares the yearly profit of a bank against its total shareholder equity as shown on its balance sheet. The higher the ROE the better. Macquarie Group Ltd’s ROE in the latest full year stood at 16.2%, meaning for every $100 of shareholder equity in the bank it produced $16.20 in yearly profit. This was over and above the banking sector average of 10.4%.
4. Capital protection
When it comes to safety and risk management, for banks, the CET1 ratio (common equity tier one) is paramount. CET1 represents the bank’s ‘safety capital’ or ‘buffer’ to protect it against complete financial collapse. In the most recent full year, Macquarie Group Ltd had a CET1 ratio of 11.4%. This was higher than the sector average.
5. Dividends & valuation
A DDM or dividend discount model is one of the best ways to value a bank’s shares. To do a DDM we have to estimate the bank’s dividends going forward and then apply a risk rating. Using this simple DDM, let’s assume the bank’s dividend payment grows at a steady rate into the future (i.e. forever) somewhere between 1.5% and 3%. For the risk rating, we will use risk rates between 9% and 14% and then average the valuations.
And the result? Our simple DDM valuation of MQG shares is $69.38. However, using an ‘adjusted’ dividend payment of $4.00 per share, the valuation goes to $45.49. The valuation compares to MQG’s current share price of $119.27.
Ultimately, although the shares might seem expensive using our simple DDM model, don’t make a decision based on this article. Please go away now and consider all of the risks and ideas we presented here. While you’re at it, you might also consider a diversified shares ETF, dividend fund or at least grab a copy of our free investment report below.
[ls_content_block id=”3302″ para=”paragraphs”]