Two of the most popular ASX gold ETFs are the ETFS Physical Gold (ASX: GOLD) ETF and BetaShares Global Gold Miners (ASX: MNRS) ETF.

View now: full list of Australian ASX ETFs.

Why Would Anyone Invest In Gold?

Gold is seen as a “safe haven” for your money. Investors view it as a relatively stable asset that retains its value even when markets or real estate are falling. Gold tends to receive a lot more interest when markets are falling or there are fears of a recession.

There are many different ways to invest in gold, the most difficult of which would be to actually buy physical gold from a mint and keep it under your bed – or probably in a safe – for a rainy day. Unfortunately, holding costs and logistics can make this strategy difficult, and there are easier options.

Key Differences: GOLD v MNRS

The ETFS Physical Gold ETF (ASX: GOLD) is designed to make life easy, allowing investors to gain exposure to physical gold via an ETF which can be bought and sold like shares. The GOLD ETF by ETF Securities is backed by physical gold held by HSBC Bank Plc and only metal which conforms with the London Bullion Market Association’s rules are accepted.

The GOLD ETF gives you direct exposure to the underlying asset (gold bars) and returns depend entirely on the price of gold. Over the last 10 years, the GOLD ETF has returned 6.17% per year and 7.62% over the last three years.

The BetaShares Global Gold Miners ETF (ASX: MNRS) takes a different approach to getting exposure to the performance of gold prices. MNRS invests in shares of the largest gold miners around the world. This is more indirect exposure to gold, and performance is affected by the price of gold, the performance of the companies and investor sentiment towards the shares.

The MNRS ETF hold shares in companies based around the world, but a large majority are in Canada, South Africa and the US. The MNRS ETF is also currency-hedged, meaning all foreign currency exposure is hedged to the Australian dollar.

Over the last three years, the fund has returned 4.64% per year, so it has underperformed the GOLD ETF, however, there is potential for huge returns, with MNRS returning 69.89% over the last 12 months.

The Fees & Costs GOLD & MNRS

The GOLD ETF has a management fee of 0.4% per year, while the MNRS ETF has a 0.57% per year management fee which is likely higher because of currency hedging.

The physical GOLD ETF would probably be considered less risky because it is a much larger ETF and is backed by physical gold. The gold miner MNRS ETF, on the other hand, is much more volatile as there are several different factors influencing the price.

To me, it would suggest that GOLD would be a better choice for a stable investment or a hedge for an existing portfolio, while the MNRS ETF has the potential for higher returns (and bigger losses).

What I Think

Gold investments can have a place in most balanced portfolios, but I consider it to be more of a hedging play than an investment for long-term growth. For that reason, I would lean more towards the physical gold ETF, but that’s just a personal preference. If you’re looking to invest in gold, it’s important to think about what the purpose of the investment is. To view more gold and commodity ETFs click here.

For our number one ETF pick, have a look at the free report below.

Want to know the name and ticker code of our #1 ASX ETF for 2019? Click here to access our free investing report, including the name, ticker code and a full analysis of our favourite ETF.

Legal disclaimer: Chances are, the information you read on the BESTETFS website may contain a mix of factual information and general financial advice. Any information/advice on this website is limited to general financial/investment advice only. The information has not taken into account your specific needs, goals or objectives, so please consider consulting a licenced and trusted adviser before acting on the information. Please read The Rask Group’s Financial Services Guide (FSG) for more information and NEVER INVEST IN AN ETF OR MANAGED FUND BEFORE READING THE PRODUCT DISCLOSURE STATEMENT (PDS). If you don't read the PDS you're practically flying blind with one arm tied behind your back. This article is authorised by Owen Raszkiewicz of The Rask Group, which is a corporate authorised representative No. 1264179 of Strawman Pty Ltd (ACN: 610 908 211) (AFSL: 501 223).

Disclosure: At the time of writing, Max does not own shares in any of the companies mentioned.